2022-07-12_PlanningCommission_YMCA_TestimonyFrom:mike heinz
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:YMCA REZONE
Date:Tuesday, July 12, 2022 4:21:06 PM
My name is Mike Heinz . I live at 168 Mineral hill rd
Mineral Wa 98355.
I am against the Rezone of Mineral lake To Resort Status For the greater Seattle
YMCA. .Shame on the Planning Commission members for not making a trip to
Mineral Lake to Visually see the Pristine area to be Rezoned. There are signs
everywhere saying No YMCA Camp and NO Mineral REZONE .Only 125 people are
there full time and the Development will Destroy the Rural character of the town. Wedon't have the roads system to support it, We have a Volunteer Fire Dept. , No Local
Police , and no Infrastructure to support this.This area is one of the last Pristine areas
left in Western Wash.The Wildlife will be impacted to move to other areas.If Lewis
County Allows the Rezone , Lewis county will not receive any Property Tax Benefitsbecause it will be zoned to a Non for Profit Organization and they will be tax exempt.
Same with the Nisqually Indian Tribe. Lewis County gets NOTHING.I urge the
Planning Commision to Vote No ON the Rezone of Mineral Lake and leave well
enough alone.Thank you for your consideration.
Mike Heinz
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
I am adamantly opposed to the rezoning request and strongly urge the planning commission to reject
the request. Stand up for Lewis County and the Mineral area, PLEASE.
I believe this Planning Commission process is broken. You are deciding to grant an overlay for Master
Plan Resort, prior to having the YMCA provide you facts to back up what they are saying. The SEPA
states nothing more than – “future development” 14 times and “building planning process” 48 times in
19 pages- this is not an answer or providing clear justification for the overlay request. The Planning
Commission also seems to put more weight on the Staff Reports than public testimony, and there is no
process to allow the public to question the property owner, in front of the Planning Commission. Also,
the YMCA used corporate double talk to NOT answer commissioner questions even at the public
testimony meeting. Commissioner Spogen asked the YMCA representative about paying taxes and the
benefit to Lewis County youth. Both times the YMCA representative “danced around” the answer and
would not provide a clear or direct statement. Both of these questions show directly a negative
response to LCC 17.12.100 Approval Criteria: #3 Public interest will be served by the amendment. If you
as the Planning Commission don't require direct "Yes or No" answers from the YMCA regarding your
questions or questions raised by the public then you are just a "rubber stamp" process.
Please question why the YMCA is "speaking out of both sides of their mouths" as it were. Please
consider the following;
1) The YMCA states economic growth for Mineral and Lewis county because of increased tourism BUT
then states that there will be minimal negative traffic impact because the majority of campers and staff
will arrive by bus, with minimal private vehicle traffic. So how will buses filled with campers and staff
generate economic growth? The camp, if like other camps, will have a limited full time/on-site staff of
maybe 5 employees, so how will this increase employment when the YMCA states they hire from all
over?
2) The commission asked a question regarding taxes and the YMCA "danced around" the answer but
basically said they would be using the tax code for master plan resort and/or forest and timber so they
will be paying close to or zero taxes. How will infrastructure in the area be paid for? Will property taxes
in Mineral area be raised to pay for the enhancements? How does that help Lewis County?
3) The YMCA will be reducing recreational opportunity to Mineral community, Lewis County and State
residence as a “community” by stating in the SEPA that they plan for future "dock and marina" (this
based on most camp structures is close to the "lodge"). To provide for a "safe swim zone" or "safe
aquatics programs" will require the YMCA for their insurance to cordon off a section of the lake hence
restricting the public or "community" at large from a portion of the public lake. How does that provide
recreational opportunity to the public while restricting access?
4) Have you read, as Commissioners, the “Environmental Permitting and Sensitive Areas Review” by
GeoEngineers (
https://lewiscountywa.gov/media/documents/2021.04.05_YMCA_Mineral_Lake_Critical_Areas_Letter_
00Lcghc.pdf
) site survey provided by the YMCA (section 4.1)? It had multiple false statements regarding wildlife and
habitat that can be challenged in court or by the WDFW biologist for the area. The site survey used
vague and cover statements as part of the findings. You should ask questions like "How can they tell if
there are elk bedding/calving/wintering areas on the property "observed from the road"? Ask them how
they were able to see no signs "observed from the road" because "limitations on amount of time and
effort " and "extensive size and challenging terrain"? So, if they didn't want to find any evidence they
just don't get out of their car on the road, because it was to brushy and steep? How is this proof?
5) Considering the environmental impact is a wide spectrum of issues but consider asking just about
transportation. How is driving 5 - 6 buses, twice a week, not including private motor vehicles, to and
from, every week for approx. 11 weeks reducing the carbon footprint of Washington State or Lewis
County, per the Governor’s plan? Is the YMCA going to be using electric buses? Where are the charging
stations?
6) Consider the "partnership" with the Nisqually tribe. Ask who approached who in the financial backing
or donation? Did the tribe approach the YMCA out of the kindness of their heart, with no strings
attached? Ask the YMCA is they have already granted the Nisqually tribe an easement? And if so for
what purpose? Since the YMCA’s experts, GeoEngineers, found “No elk or evidence of elk
concentrations were observed during site reconnaissance.”, section 4.3, then why did the YMCA grant
“will offer opportunities for game and bird hunting to fulfill cultural and traditional experiences” to the
Nisqually tribe.” Per the YMCA website - https://www.seattleymca.org/blog/partnership-nisqually-
indian-tribe-new-overnight-camp-and-environmental-education-center
Shawn and Laura Seeger
676 Pleasant Valley Rd.
Mineral, Wa. 98355
206-920-1446
wabowhunter@hotmail.com
My name is Shawn Seeger, and as a Mineral resident, I am adamantly opposed to the “Rezone” request by the YMCA of
Greater Seattle.
First understand that I have been involved with youth programs and camps for approximately 12 years, with BSA
and church organizations. And I believe in exposing youth from all walks of life and communities to outdoor programs.
That being said, I believe the YMCA camp being proposed will have very negative consequence to the Mineral
community and surrounding area. There are many reasons, including major traffic increases, major impacts to wildlife,
and potential safety emergency services and drinking water health risks to the youth that would be attending the future
camp.
I am frustration with both the YMCA of Greater Seattle for their disingenuous, misleading and untruthful
statements, both written and verbal, and the Lewis County Planning Commission and Staff for being outwardly excited
about the project, prior to having all serious and critical facts and impacts. If or when the rezone is approved it will
basically be letting the “Genie out of the bottle”. The YMCA is providing you with the answers you want to hear, they are
using a phased approach so as to have you approve the rezone without all of the impacts of future phases, and they are
misleading you with numbers of campers, staff and vehicles by omitting key wording, similar to, only 400 campers and
100 staff, omitting “per week” for an “11 week season/session”. That mathematically would significantly increase area
traffic! By doing these and other slight of hand/word tricks they are hopeful they will get what they want or perhaps
already know they will get what they want. The YMCA is being untruthful when they say they will not take a portion of
the lake. I believe they are aware of the legal and insurance requirements for an aquatics program, since they have
stated in their filings they would have a dock and marina, they will be required to cordon off, causing state and
community forfeiter, a portion of the lake for a “safe swim zone”.
The YMCA has also provided you with “GeoEngineers of Seattle, “Environmental Permitting and Sensitive Areas
Review” of the YMCA Mineral Lake Property – Due Diligence Phase, March 8, 2021.” This review was only intended to
support what the YMCA wants. GeoEngineers employees that conducted this “reconnaissance” trip stated “No elk or
evidence of elk concentrations were observed during site reconnaissance.” maybe this is because they didn’t want to
see evidence, “from the road” and were limited “due to time” and “challenging terrain”, because this property has been
used by locals and those familiar with the area for generations for both deer and elk hunting. And why would the YMCA
enter into agreement with their “partners”, the Nisqually Tribe, to allow for “opportunities for game and bird hunting to
fulfill cultural and traditional experiences.” If there are no elk or birds to hunt?
I am both disappointed and disturbed by your willingness and at times excited nature towards a project that has
many major negative impacts on the Mineral community and is opposed by a large number of my Mineral neighbors.
What if this was your neighborhood?
You the Planning Commission and Staff seem to be willing to accept the YMCA’s request and seem to be willing
to say “in the next steps of the planning process” or “during the permitting process” for roads, mitigations, and
abatements “that issue will be addressed” or “if something is found then we can stop it then”. This is potentially
approving a project by kicking the problem down the road both literally and figuratively. You have the power to stop this
project NOW, before it even gets started. It’s your job, perhaps even honoring deceased District 3 County Councilman
Gary Stampers views to “watch out for the little guy”. That “little guy” being the Mineral community and rural Lewis
County residence.
Please listen to me, and the community that will be negatively impacted, whom you are supposed to be
representing, not the YMCA of Greater Seattle, and DO NOT approve this rezone request.
Shawn and Laura Seeger
676 Pleasant Valley Rd.
Mineral, Wa. 98355
206-920-1446
wabowhunter@hotmail.com
From:Tammy Martin
To:Mindy Brooks; Lee Napier
Subject:FW: [Spam?] Fwd: YMCA
Date:Tuesday, July 12, 2022 4:01:54 PM
Attachments:Mineral Station.docx
Importance:High
Please see the public comment from Kurt Roehm for tonight’s meeting.
Sincerely,
Tammy Martin
Administrative Asst. Sr.
Lewis County Commissioners Office
(360)740-1391
tammy.martin@lewiscountywa.gov
From: Kurt Roehm <lcfd9com2@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 12, 2022 3:45 PM
To: Tammy Martin <Tammy.Martin@lewiscountywa.gov>
Subject: [Spam?] Fwd: YMCA
Importance: Low
Hello Tammy, Here is a statement from the Officers of Mineral 9 Fire regarding the ongoing negotiationswith the YMCA's consultants. ---------- Forwarded message ---------From: Lewis County Fire District 9 <lcfd9@lewiscounty.com>Date: Mon, Jul 11, 2022 at 9:15 PMSubject: YMCATo: <lcfd9com2@gmail.com>
Here is the info requested.
--Open WebMail Project (http://openwebmail.org)
--Kurt RoehmFire Commissioner 2Mineral Fire and Rescue
Lewis County Fire Protection District #9’s Command Staff have been in talks with Modern Volunteer Fire
Service regarding the districts needs and the YMCA’s proposed camp on Mineral Lake. The Command
staff has identified that without a good foundation the district won’t be able to continue existing
services to its patrons and the YMCA. The Command staff has discussed the need for a complete
remodel/replacement of our current fire station as well as looking into paid staff. Built in the 1960’s the
facilities are no longer in compliance with WAC 296-305 and recommendations by NFPA. We currently
have no decontamination facilities for both personnel and firefighting gear. Our current septic cannot
handle what use it has currently and that’s just a toilet and sink. Our office space is in the apparatus
bays and exposes our members to dust and contaminates. We must double stack our first line apparatus
because of lack of room. The command staff has done their research and have come up with the
minimum cost of a station to meet our growing needs at 11 million dollars. This would include facilities
to house paid personnel doing shift work.
From:Dick and Paula Hopkins
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:[Spam?] YMCA rezone proposal
Date:Tuesday, July 12, 2022 2:36:05 AM
Importance:Low
Ms Brooks
Please incorporate these comments into the official comments for the YMCA rezoning.
1. The YMCA proposed camp will have little impact to the Mineral area.A. Environmental impacts will be negligible
B. Aquifer issues are not yet assessed, but deep wells should have little impact on neighborswells.
C. Wildlife will not be effected.D. Noise will be no worse than the drunken fishermen on opening weekend.
2. Positive impacts.
A. Kids and adults will have the Forestry education and outdoor experiences. B. Donation of vollenteer assistance of fish into the lake and financial contributions.
C. Revenue to the local store, merchant's and contractors.
3. Mineral was founded on mining, then logging and saw mills, and became services resourceand assets and recreation. NOTHING STAYS THE SAME. With each of these changes, the
population worried, fretted and opposed change, but the town is still thriving.
Dick & Paula Hopkins428 -29 Mineral Creek Road
Mineral WA 98355
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Maureen Upsahl
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Mineral Rezone
Date:Monday, July 11, 2022 6:48:20 PM
July 11, 2022
M. Brooks and Lewis County Council,
We purchased our property in Mineral in 2014 after visiting the area for several years.
Mineral residents take excellent care of the lake. Volunteers check water quality and clean upthe designated swim area, and organize other work projects. We have been impressed by the
caring community here and look forward to many more adventures here as we host ourchildren and grandchildren at our peaceful, quiet home.
The size of the proposed YMCA camp seems overwhelming. I am confused by the lack of
communication regarding this development and note that there seems to be no interest innegotiating a smaller version of this camp.
I certainly hope that the decision makers on the Lewis County Council spend time here before
approving this large scale camp. Do you know how quiet it is here? The noise pollution, harmto wildlife habitats, traffic on roads that are not equipped to handle the extra vehicles, and
contamination to Mineral Lake need more attention by Lewis County officials.
Negotiators need to compromise. A camp with a much smaller lakefront footprint and cabinsand support buildings to accommodate fewer campers should be considered. Surely the
Nisqually tribe would agree that this would be a more appropriate way to provide YMCAcampers a quality experience without disrupting quiet quality of life, and pristine lake
conditions.
YMCA officials, Mineral should not have to be your answer to lack of quality spaces forcampers. Compromise with a smaller version of your plan. Keep looking for other options
across our beautiful state. Provide your campers quality nature escapes using more smallcamps across Washington. Campers can have an educational, recreational experience without
it being lakefront. Continue with your philosophy of loving and caring for our natural areas.Teach campers the value of compromising to conserve resources.
Please consider negotiating a compromise.
Sincerely,
Maureen and Al Upsahl
112 Front St. W.Mineral, WA 98355
(253)874-3444
From:ready readyproducts.co
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:YMCA
Date:Monday, July 11, 2022 3:27:29 PM
To the Lewis County Commissioners,
My name is Kurt Roehm, I reside in Mineral at PO Box 19. I am neither for nor
against The YMCA opening a youth camp on Mineral Lake.
The issue here is private property rights. If they can clear all the hurdles in
front of them then they deserve to develop their property as they choose.
The overall economy relies on growth to fuel it. Trees grow for fifty years then
they are harvested and the loggers and all the connected Partys benefit from it.
However, what about the residents that need a job and they are not a logger?
It is the job of the Lewis County Commissioners to manage growth for all
residents. There are very few jobs in Mineral.
People are nervous about change. The Elderly are worried about picking up the
extra cost in taxes associated with growth.
Sincerely,
Kurt Roehm
PO Box 19
Mineral, WA 98355
Get Outlook for Android
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Dora Hale
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Mineral YMCA
Date:Monday, July 11, 2022 1:39:44 PM
Dear Mindy,
I have some concerns about the YMCA camp on Mineral Lake.
1. How does YMCA intend to incorporate and promote Christianity at thecamp? As the C in the name is Christian, I trust this will be part of programscriteria.
2. Shallow well issue. How will proposed well(S) drilled on YMCA propertyaffect the shallow wells in Mineral? My well is 68 feet. This is much concernfor me as I cannot afford to drill deeper.
3. It is my personal opinion that the camp has more positives thannegatives. However, if the rezoning issue will raise our taxes here in town,that is not an option for retired low income households. Should any newbuilding around lake, YMCA or other owners need to pay the costs of roads,water, septic, and any other amenities they may want to pass on to the localtax payers. Camp or new housing want the amenities, then they can pay forthem.
Thank you for passing this along to commissioners and other interestedparties.
Sincerely, Dora Hale Mineral, Wa--Open WebMail Project (https://linkprotect.cudasvc.com/url?a=http%3a%2f%2fopenwebmail.org&c=E,1,fR6b5f1odCQoxG5FprfWzY0t8DrD0n7UCm5tNoVKiUoHmqqc9-
Nnu_zbCMalqCBYCSgji6680xXK2009np8sKsIQE8qIa5CtMcI4AvTnYBMH5-vq&typo=1)
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure the message is legitimate before openingit.
From:Danielle Githens
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Support of YMCA Rezone - Mineral Lake
Date:Tuesday, June 28, 2022 5:46:50 PM
Dear Ms. Brooks,
I am writing in support of the YMCA of Greater Seattle's application to rezone its Mineral Lake property to
facilitate the development of an overnight camp. The Y's overnight camps provide a safe and fun opportunity for
youth to connect with nature instead of technology, where kids can challenge themselves through new activities and
live with others outside their family unit.
My personal connection to this project is as a volunteer member of the Y's Camping and Outdoor Leadership
Advisory Board and a member of the search committee that identified Mineral Lake as a potential location for the
Y's next overnight camp. Our search committee explored a number of properties over many years. Among other
factors, we were drawn to Mineral Lake for its natural beauty, location on a body of water, and proximity to Mt.
Rainier. The opportunity to secure a large tract of land was also important - for recreation and educational
opportunities as well as to provide a natural buffer between campers and future development around the lake. It is
important that campers feel like they are out in nature - away from neighbors and with infrastructure that blends in
with the natural environment - benefitting both the Y and its neighbors.
Please support this project by approving the requested rezone.
Thank you for your consideration,
Danielle Githens
.
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure the message is legitimate before opening
it.
From:Alexis Shellenback
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Mineral Re-Zone Public Comment
Date:Tuesday, June 28, 2022 4:59:16 PM
Lewis County Planning Board of Commissioners
Community Development 2025 NE Kresky Ave
Chehalis, WA 98532
Commissioners,
I, along as well as many other residents of the Mineral, Washington
oppose the Mineral Re-Zone.
I have been coming to the Mineral, Washington to camp, fish, and swim
since I was a young child. I admire the beauty and peacefulness the
area brings.
The proposed Re-Zone stands to change the landscape and have a
negative impact on the residents of Mineral, Washington. There will be
a significant increase in vehicle traffic, road noise due to vehicle and
pedestrian traffic. This will have a negative impact on the peace and
tranquility this area is known for.
The water availability study is completely inaccurate since it was
conducted during the wettest part of the year. Therefore they cannot
show that it will not have a negative impact on the water supply to the
community during the hottest season of the year.
I, along with my family and many other residents of the Mineral,
Washington oppose the Mineral Re-Zone.
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Jami Lund
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Rezone issues that come before the Planning Commission
Date:Friday, July 1, 2022 12:04:19 AM
Hello,
I read that some are hoping for the Commission to recommend keeping the existing, strict land
restrictions in place for Mineral Lake.
My hope is that the Planning Commission will take all opportunities to increase flexibility forpeople to utilize their land.
I believe opportunity, housing, and even the use of resources to meet human needs are all
artificially suppressed by the existing planning policies and land use restrictions.
I would hope that the Commission would not let some people use the power of government tofurther stifle other people's land uses. Instead, urge the county commission to pursue more
vibrant land use by revising the Growth Management Act plan._________
Jami Lund(360) 918-3990
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
YMCA OF GREATER SEATTLE
909 Fourth Ave , Seattle WA 98104
seattleymca.org
July 5, 2022 Lewis County Planning Commission 351 NW North St. Chehalis, WA 98532 Dear Chairwoman Spogen and Members of the Planning Commission: We respect and appreciate the due diligence the Planning Commission is exercising to ensure that you have the necessary information to make a recommendation regarding the proposed Comprehensive Plan Map Amendment to establish a Master Plan Resort overlay on current Forest Resource Land for our proposed youth and family camp at Mineral Lake, and to ensure that the public has an additional opportunity to share their views. To support you in that due diligence, the YMCA of Greater Seattle (YMCA), as the applicant, is offering these additional comments on the record to address several issues discussed during the June 28th public hearing. The Question Before You We believe that it’s important to remember that the purpose of this application is not to spell out every detail of how the proposed camp will be designed, built, and operated. Many of the questions that you or the public have about those details will be addressed in the subsequent application for and review of a binding site plan. For the moment, the issues are whether (1) the proposed overlay is consistent with the provisions of the Growth Management Act and countywide planning policies; (2) there is a demonstrated need for the rezone; (3) public interest will be served by the application; and (4) the change does not represent spot zoning. The County staff analyzed these four issues and concluded that the YMCA application should be recommended for approval. The Purpose of the Project The most important public benefit of the proposed camp is that it will provide new opportunities for the youth and families of Lewis County and from throughout Western Washington to develop a stronger understanding and appreciation for the outdoors and for the protection of our natural resources. The YMCA’s current camp facilities, which have been providing such opportunities for more than a century, are unable to meet demand that has grown over the decades, meaning too many youth are missing out on these important lessons. Additionally, in 2022, the Washington state legislature recognized the need for expanding outdoor education opportunities and enacted a bill designed to provide all 5th and 6th graders with meaningful, multi-day experiences. There are not currently sufficient facilities in Washington state to meet this objective, and the camp at Mineral Lake would be a vital addition to support this important initiative.
Page 2
Finally, we would like to again emphasize the YMCA’s commitment to ensuring that a lack of financial resources does not stand as a barrier to local youth and families enjoying these benefits. Currently, one in five campers at our existing camps receives scholarship support to make their camping experience possible. Alternatives In making your decision, it may be helpful to consider the alternatives, both for the YMCA and for the subject property. During the hearing, at least one member of the public testified that the YMCA should consider other properties, specifically alongside a lake in King County. The reality is that our staff researched and analyzed potential camp properties for five years before selecting the Mineral Lake site. Sites of this size and quality are simply rare in western Washington. Indeed, this site provides a unique opportunity to create our first new camp facility in a century and to safeguard the natural environment. Before pursuing ownership of the property, the YMCA conducted extensive due diligence, which is summarized in the application and confirms the viability of the site for this project. Additional detailed studies will be conducted and reported as part of the binding site plan application process. The other issue that warrants careful consideration is the alternative future for the property itself. As was explained during the hearing, if the overlay is not adopted, the property will revert to its current Forest Resource Land designation. Approved uses within that designation include 20-acre residential lots, 25 of which have already been plotted on the property. Each of these could be developed into a large homesite, with separate wells, septic systems, docks and powered watercraft. The proposed, a camp facility, using a small portion of the property, which your staff has determined poses no significant environmental impact with appropriate mitigation measures. Public Input It is our understanding that you extended the public comment period to run through your July 12th meeting in order to ensure that members of the public are given more time to provide input. It is worth noting the multiple opportunities for public input that have been and will continue to be provided in the application and review process, including:
• A period for public comment once our application was deemed complete and a
notice of application was published by the staff of the Lewis County Community
Development Department;
• The initial June 28th public hearing on the overlay / rezone application
• The newly scheduled July 12th public hearing on the overlay / rezone application
• A public hearing before the Lewis County Commissioners as part of their review
process
• Provided the overlay / rezone is approved, the YMCA would continue its technical
studies and begin site design in order to submit a binding site plan.
• The approval of the binding site plan and related permits would include additional
avenues for public input
All of these opportunities for input to the official record are being supplemented by additional voluntary community engagement that has already been undertaken by the YMCA and will continue as appropriate.
Page 3
We recognize that, despite these multiple opportunities for engagement, members of the Commission and members of the public may have unanswered questions. However, as stated earlier in this letter, issues like road and traffic impacts, emergency response, or the design of the camp’s water and wastewater systems are issues that will be addressed during the site design / binding site plan development, submission, and approval phase of the process. Those questions can only be answered if the overlay / rezone application is approved, making way for the creation of that binding site plan. In short, your recommendation to approve the first step in the review process is required in order to move to the second phase, which will answer the questions you and the public may still have. The “Master Planned Resort” Designation To some degree, both the YMCA as the applicant and the Planning Commission as the initial review agency are hamstrung by the fact that the Growth Management Act designation for this type of proposal uses the “master-planned resort” terminology. We recognize that the word “resort” can conjure up images of larger scale development of condominiums, restaurants, marinas, golf courses, casinos, or other facilities. However, the YMCA has been consistent in publicly explaining it has no interest or intention in building or operating that type of “resort.” We are in the business of providing camping and outdoor learning opportunities to youth and families in a smaller and more rustic setting. More importantly, the language that is before you in your staff recommendation specifically and explicitly excludes those larger-scale facilities on the property. The language effectively would limit our options to the type of camp we are proposing: a modestly sized central dining hall with number of smaller cabins for campers and staff. We remain comfortable with that restrictive language, as it aligns with our plans for the site. Members of the public, especially any who are concerned with what a “resort” might entail, can refer to the narrow definitions, exclusionary language, and timelines proposed by staff for your recommendation to the County Commissioners. The Role of the Nisqually Indian Tribe The YMCA has been very public in acknowledging the critical funding support that has been provided by the Nisqually Indian Tribe. This funding has made possible our initial purchase of a portion of the property, much as other donors provide resources to support our other facilities and programs. We are grateful to the Tribe for their support, and we look forward to working with them in developing cultural, historical, and outdoor education opportunities both for tribal members and for non-tribal youth and families. However, as we have repeatedly stated, the YMCA will be the sole owner of the property and will be the decision-maker in how the camp is built and operated. Lake Access The exact design of our water recreation area will be covered as part of the binding site plan application. However, those who are concerned about whether our camp facility could impede general public use of the lake should consider the design and use of the facilities at our existing Camps Colman and Orkila. It bears repeating that safety protocols and lifeguard-to-camper ratios limit both the size of our water recreation areas and the number of campers who are on or in the water at any given time. We are likely to have no more than 15 to 20 kayaks or canoes on the water at any given time; opponents’ nightmare scenarios of hundreds of campers clogging an entire portion of the lake are simply unrealistic. It is also important to again point out that we do not use motorboats, jet skis, or other motor-powered craft in our camp activities, which limits any impact on our neighbors or the lake itself.
Page 4
Phased Build-Out As we have publicly stated, we expect the full build-out of the Mineral Lake camp to take five to ten years, based on factors such as permitting and fundraising. To respond to one concern raised at the June 28th hearing, we want to emphasize that this does not mean that there would be year-round construction activity taking place for the next decade. It simply means that we would phase construction over some period until we reach the design and provisions of the binding site plan. In closing, we hope that this additional information will prove helpful in your deliberations. The YMCA remains committed to transparency regarding our plans and to continue to have candid, constructive, and respectful engagement with both Lewis County officials and the local community. Please let us know if there is anything else we can provide. Thank you. Sincerely, Gwen Ichinose Bagley SVP, Youth Development Officer YMCA of Greater Seattle
From:Jen Sonstelie Irish
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Mineral Lake hearing comments
Date:Thursday, July 7, 2022 10:12:22 AM
Hello Mindy,
Below are my comments for the Board of County Commissioners meeting on July 12
regarding the YMCA request for Mineral Lake rezoning.
Thank you,
Jen
----
Commissioners,
I am writing in support of the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. I began attendingYMCA Camp Orkila in 1987 and spent a significant part of my summers there for the next 11 years;first as a camper, and later as a counselor. I’ve brought my own family and many friends to familycamp and my daughter has attended both Orkila and Colman. My experiences at Orkila taught me torespect the environment, value diversity, communicate through problems, and be part of a team.
YMCA Camps teach values I’m sure we all see as essential in a highly complex world — respect,
responsibility, honesty, and caring. They also provide many children (50% of whom attend on some
level of scholarship) their first introduction to the outdoors. Both camps currently run by the YMCA
of Greater Seattle have extensive outdoor education programs. And both are currently at capacity.
To serve more youth and families, a new camp is needed.
The letters many members of the Mineral Lake community submitted made me sad, as I think thetwo sides of this issue may overlap on more than they realize. We all want to preserve beautifulnatural sites. And I expect we all agree teaching youth and families about environmental stewardshipis more important today than ever before.
Respect of the environment is not a lesson best learned in a classroom in the city. It is imprinted on
people’s hearts via experiences in beautiful places like Mineral Lake. Through the work of a camp
here, generations of children will learn to be stewards of the environment.
I understand that change can be frightening. Most of the people living at Mineral Lake did not attendCamp Orkila or Camp Colman and it is therefore difficult to envision what that change might looklike. But my decades of involvement with YMCA Camps tell me the Y will develop the site responsibly(both current camps still feel extremely rural) and do their utmost to partner with the localcommunity, addressing concerns and creating programming to benefit the Mineral Lake communitywhen the camp is up and running.
Thank you for considering my comments.
Sincerely,
Jen Irish
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Jay Satz
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Gwen Ichinose-Bagley; Aaron Parker
Subject:[Spam?] support for YMCA Camp plans at Mineral Lake
Date:Thursday, July 7, 2022 10:40:48 AM
Attachments:image001.pngimage002.png
Importance:Low
Ms. Mindy BrooksSenior Long Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks,
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the Greater Seattle YMCA’s plans for buildingan overnight camp on Mineral Lake. As a member of the Board of the Camping and Outdoor
Leadership Branch of the Y, I am a true believer in the power of our camp experiences to havea profound, positive impact on the youth we serve. I know this from experience, since as a
young boy, my participation in YMCA camps instilled in me an environmental ethic and deepcommitment to building and supporting community that has lasted throughout my life.
As a thirty five year veteran professional of the Conservation Corps movement in the United
States (my “day” job), I am also very aware of the power of youth in action in service to theircommunities, and in particular, to our country’s public lands. For over thirty of my years of
service in our industry, I have had very strong ties to Mount Rainier National Park, where Ihave been involved in running youth conservation service programs, and I feel that I know the
area, ecosystem and surrounding communities well.
Others have eloquently spoken to the positive power of YMCA programs, and whileembracing those sentiments, I wish to focus my remarks in responding to some of the concerns
members of the community have expressed regarding the potential for the presence of ourcamp to negatively impact their community. Regarding concerns on the impact camp would have on medical/fire response: I strongly
believe that rather than taxing existing emergency response, the presence of our camp willenhance community response. We will be establishing a camp medical program that will
include a medical facility, staffed by volunteer nurses, physician assistants and physicians.Modeled on our Camp Orkila medical program on Orcas Island (which is a model praised
internationally throughout the overnight camp community), not only will the YMCA be ableto take care of virtually any medical instance within the camp environment, but the facility
would be available for non-camp medical emergencies from the Mineral Lake community.
It is also important to note that we typically have staff on site at our camps (all year) who arecertified Wilderness First Responders, Wilderness EMTs and EMTS. These highly qualified
outdoor professionals add value for us as we run our programs, but for those qualified staffwho would live at camp year round, some would likely be part of the volunteer effort to
support the community emergency response in the Mineral Lake community (when my sonRory - a certified EMT - was on the Environmental Education staff at Camp Orkila, he also
volunteered two days a week for Orcas Fire and Rescue, as well as being on call). Regarding our potential relationship with the community: Our camps have always workeddiligently and effectively to be a positive part of the communities where the camps are sited.
During the first difficult year of the pandemic for example, the Directors of both CampColman and Camp Orkila led the way in identifying and solving challenges within their
communities. Our camps ended up providing meals for in-need individuals, providing openspace for classes for the school district, and in some cases providing child care. Rather than
taking on burdens, the Mineral Lake community will actually have expanded resources due toour presence. We are absolutely committed to being good and active neighbors.
Regarding the impact on rural character of the area: I truly understand the concerns some
folks have around losing the sense of solitude and live there because of minimal development.Of course, some things will change – BUT, a fundamental outcome of our mission is to help a
new generation of mostly urban dwellers experience rural life for the first time, and value it.We are creating supporters, appreciators and eventually voters who unlike many urban
dwellers, will be attuned to the importance of maintaining rural and wild Washington. Regarding the YMCA’s commitment to Stewardship and Environmental Education:Stewardship is a major ethos of our organization which we practice every day. Whether it is
reducing our garbage and food waste footprint, minimizing artificial light impact on beautifulnight skies, managing our water system and waste water on Orcas, or teaching these principles
to a new generation, we have lived our commitment to steward our natural and financialresources. We will be guided by “building green” principles in developing our infrastructure.
We also have the opportunity to run stewardship programs at our camp and in partnership withMount Rainier National Park.
But most importantly, we are introducing youth who for their whole lives, have only seen
Mount Rainier (in the postcard like distance that had no real meaning to them), and for thefirst time, they will have an experience that will help them understand the importance of
maintaining an ecosystem that provides water, electricity, salmon and so much more to themall the way back to their Seattle and Tacoma communities. They will understand that
protecting this rural/wild ecosystem is essential to their home ecosystem working and thriving.I think this part of our mission will do more to help protect the rural nature of the area than
trying to keep folks out. Economic Opportunity for the community: And finally, building, maintaining and staffingour camp will be a very positive driver for the local economy. We are going to provide a lot of
jobs.
Thank you for the thoughtfulness, deliberateness and inclusivity of your process. If I canprovide anther further information or insight, please let me know.
Kind regards,
Jay
Jay A. Satz(he, him, his) why pronouns matter
Senior Director, Partnerships and Innovation
Northwest Youth Corps and Idaho Conservation Corps(206) 550 5977
Boise, Eugene, Tacomawww.nwyouthcorps.org
Facebook | Twitter | Instagram
To learn more on the most up to date status of our covid management protocols and/or programs,please visit: https://www.nwyouthcorps.org/m/covid19
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
Attention: Mindy Brooks,
Senior Long Range Planner, Lewis County Planning commission Thanks for this opportunity to give comment on the YMCA camp proposal . My name is Lynn Bishop. I’m not a Mineral resident, I live in Morton, but I know a lot of Mineral “kids”. I don’t know much about the water supply and traffic issues, but I do know about camps and kids.
After the last horrific school shooting in Texas, many of us became
frustrated with the same old response. We all feel the urge to do
something, but it just generally boils down to going on line and giving our
opinions on what others should do: the police, the school, the mental health professionals, the gun lobby, and congress. Lots of opinions, and suggestions, but that’s not really doing something, is it? And it doesn’t seem enough anymore to say “you’re in my thoughts and prayers”. This is why I’m writing on Mineral’s page.
I’ve lived and taught in Eastern Lewis County for a long time and know
what a great place it is for kids to grow up. We can be close to nature here,
with plenty of trees, lakes, rivers , etc. And we know our kids here have
advantages because of that and the type of character it builds.
I grew up in another beautiful place, Northern Minnesota, with plenty of places to meet nature, forests, and lakes. My life was full of camping experiences, as a camper, as a counselor, and I know the benefits and life-changing experiences it can bring. I also know how children respond to positive encouragement.
My thoughts are now with young boys growing up in quite a different
atmosphere , one where they do not have this experience-often spending
time alone or online feeling left out and learn to hate themselves and
everyone else. Maybe we could start here.
If you had something that you could share that could prevent another tragedy-you would, I know you would. We take all this that we have for granted, but what if we could share it with some of these kids that have no other chance? What if, out of the 400 campers, 10 could change direction?
In one year alone, we could make a difference. This truly is a chance. We
have something here that could change many lives.
I know the benefits of camping, I have seen life-changing experiences with
kids at camp. In addition to learning to love nature, they learn to work together, to share, to become natural helpers, to develop leadership skills, life skills and to trust themselves and others. Let’s not hesitate, let’s see if we can change history.
Thank you for this chance to speak. Lynn Bishop
From:Gerry Olson
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:Mineral Lake Rezone Gerry Olson
Date:Tuesday, June 28, 2022 1:45:44 PM
Hi Mindy,
I'm Gerald Olson, I am fortunate to live in Mineral. Mineral Lake is a very special place. It isone of a kind, by far the most beautiful place in Lewis County. The lake is in the mountains
reflecting Mt. Rainer. Cougar, elk, otter, martin, bear, eagle, osprey etc. live here. There is nolake left like this anywhere on the plant. It's the last undeveloped lake. To develop Mineral
Lake would be a criminal act against mother nature and everyone else. Of course it is notabout the children. There are plenty of more suitable sites for the children. If the tribe really
cared about mother nature and the children they would turn the property into a nature preservefor future generations and children yet to come. Mineral Lake is a pristine wilderness. once
you develop it you can't undo it. It can't be recreated. It's lost for future generations. Itshouldn't be about money, but it is. It's all about money! It's about greed! Don't cut up and
destroy the Gem of the Northwest! Stop yet another atrocious act against mother nature.Don't make it about money. Make your decision with your heart and soul. Save the last lake!
Leave it alone!
Sincerely Gerald Olson
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Megan Sathre
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Megan Sathre
Subject:FW: YMCA Public Hearing Testimony
Date:Tuesday, June 28, 2022 10:22:08 AM
From: Margot Page <Margot.Page@outlook.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 28, 2022 9:59 AM
To: Megan Sathre <Megan.Sathre@lewiscountywa.gov>
Subject: YMCA Public Hearing Testimony
Hi Megan,
I am a Mineral resident who is strongly in support of the YMCA camp, though I confess I don’t know
a lot about what the rezone means.
There are so many folks here who support, but the anti-voices are the loud ones. I’d like to speak in
support of the YMCA camp if you think that voice (not super educated on the rezone but
philosophically very supportive) will be helpful. I will be joining by Zoom.
Please let me know. Thanks, and thanks very much for all of the work you are doing. I have been at
the community meetings and been frankly ashamed of some of the voices from my town.
Best,
Margot Page
102-52 Roundtop Road
Mineral
206.930.6501
Sent from Mail for Windows
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure themessage is legitimate before opening it.
From:Heinz, Hannah
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:YMCA Rezone Inquiry
Date:Tuesday, June 28, 2022 10:42:58 AM
Lewis County Planning Commission,
My name is Hannah Heinz, and my family has a home at 168 Mineral Hill Rd in Mineral,
WA. In 2004, we purchased our property and spent many years developing and building wherewe call home today. We enjoy the peaceful lifestyle that rural living has to offer, including
fishing Mineral lake and enjoying the rich abundance of wildlife who live here. The peopleliving in this small community intentionally sought out rural living in order to get away from
the hustle and bustle; with specific regards to keeping it rural and peaceful.
Upon hearing of the YMCA of greater Seattle implementing plans to create hundreds ofcampsites, in addition to other out buildings, we were shocked. This plan would provide
accommodations for far more people than the current sum of Mineral residents. Additionally,we don’t have the resources to safely put this plan into effect. The fire department consists of
few volunteer firemen and only one EMT. The roads are narrow and few, bordering very steepwooded terrain while buses and other forms of transit are expected to come here. This will
additionally result in destruction of forest land and displacement of the wildlife native to thisarea i.e. osprey, eagles, otters, deer, elk, and bear.
While these challenges bring seemingly simple fixes, the residents of Lewis County will be
at the hefty literal expense of this project. The type of infrastructure being planned for wouldalso completely transform the peaceful environment we call home, and bring an abrupt end to
this area of rural living as we know it.
There are numerous areas, such as Kapowsin Lake, that already have establishedcommunities that are far more equipped to handle this volume of people and public activities.
An alternative location would also create less disruption to the ecosystem and result in lowercosts of resources.
Mineral Lake and the town of Mineral have a longstanding nickname of being the “gem” of
the northwest, and we strive to maintain our unique and beautiful way of rural living. I ask thatour commissioners think long and hard on this issue, and to please consider other locations for
this project.
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Hannah Heinz
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
From:Heather Siegel
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:[Spam?] Letter of Support for Mineral Lake YMCA Camp
Date:Monday, June 27, 2022 6:59:45 PM
Importance:Low
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. As a
longtime Y staff my view is undoubtedly biased but as someone who has spent over 13 years working
at resident/overnight camp I can attest to the value that getting people outdoors, as well as how it
benefits our state and world.
I started working at YMCA camps in 2003 at YMCA Camp Orkila’s Outdoor Environmental Education
Program. That experience changed my life as it showed me how the outdoors can be a teach tool for
youth to adults. We provided experiences for schools and families during the non-summer months,
which I had not experienced before. That experience as an outdoor educator inspired me to continue
to find more ways to make the outdoor accessible to people. I stayed in the camping world until 2014
when I transitioned my career to facility branches, but I carry many of the lessons I learned from my
years in camping into my work today. The outdoors gave me a space to learn that I had not had in
traditional education, which is the experience I saw in many of the youth I got to work with over the
years.
The Y core values are always taught (honesty, respect, caring and responsibility) in our youth
programming and I’ve seen these values bring kids together who would have never seen eye to eye in
normal settings. I think this is something our world needs a lot more of these days.
For these reasons, I urge your approval of this project. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
HEATHER SIEGEL Pronouns: She, Her, Hers
Branch Executive DirectorBellevue Family YMCAP: 425.990.6972www.seattlymca.org
YMCA C19
This e-mail, including attachments, may contain confidential and/or proprietary information for the use of the individual(s) orentity(ies) to which it is addressed. If the reader of this e-mail is not the intended recipient or an authorized agent of such an
entity, the reader is hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mailin error, please notify the sender by replying to this message and delete the e-mail immediately.
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure themessage is legitimate before opening it.
From:eleanor munro
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Gwen Ichinose Bagley
Subject:[Spam?] YMCA request to rezone land at Mineral Lake
Date:Monday, June 27, 2022 6:29:36 PM
Importance:Low
I have been associated with the YMCA’s camping programs since about 1948. I am very
familiar with all facets of the YMCA camping program. It serves children from as far away asMinnesota and Alaska. The program is outstanding in teaching young campers independent
living skills, civility, teamwork and leadership. The program makes a contribution to thequality of life in the Puget Sound basin.
Our two resident camps, Orkila and Colman, are operating at capacity. We need to create anew camp that offers a different experience.
I have visited the Mineral Lake site. I feel that it could become an excellent natural location
that would not require extensive alteration (logging, road building, ditching, etc.)
For these reasons I urge the Lewis County Planning Commission and Board of CountyCommissioners to approve the rezone application.
Allan W Munro
1925 41st Ave SWSeattle WA 98116
206-937-9825
--
Eleanor Munro
(206) 370-1374 |eleanor.munro21@gmail.com
1925 41st Ave SW, Seattle WA 98116
IMPORTANT: The contents of this email and any attachments are confidential. They are intended for the named recipient(s) only. Ifyou have received this email by mistake, please notify the sender immediately and do not disclose the contents to anyone or makecopies thereof.
Create your own email signature
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Tara Jones
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:[Spam?] Y Support for Mineral Lake Application
Date:Thursday, June 16, 2022 4:52:12 PM
Importance:Low
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. In my
opinion, the YMCA proposal is the best possible use for this property and would offer one of the
lowest development impacts to the surrounding community, while providing both economic and
educational benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and
have experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to
bringing equity and inclusion to the outdoors, conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a
culturally responsive manner is important for today and future generations. We understand thatBIPoC youth, who experience marginalization due to race and other oppressed intersections, havefaced multiple barriers in accessing culturally responsive outdoor education. At the Y, we know thatyoung people thrive in an outdoor environment, and that the environment will benefit from expandedand equitable youth outdoor leadership.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing
development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an
additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use
in the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part
of Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10
years and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax
exemption as a non-profit organization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax
revenues that would benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education
opportunities for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the
Legislature found that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing
outdoor education experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those
opportunities for schools and students. For these reasons, I urge your approval of this project. Thank
you.
Sincerely,
Tara Jones
Tara JonesSVP and Chief Philanthropy and Experience OfficerShe/her/hers C 248.229.5315P 206.382.5016
YMCA of Greater Seattle909 Fourth AvenueSeattle, Washington 98104seattleymca.org
The Y: We’re for youth development, healthy living and social responsibility.
YMCA C19
This e-mail, including attachments, may contain confidential and/or proprietary information for the use of the individual(s) orentity(ies) to which it is addressed. If the reader of this e-mail is not the intended recipient or an authorized agent of such anentity, the reader is hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail
in error, please notify the sender by replying to this message and delete the e-mail immediately.
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Eric Waters
To:Mindy Brooks; Preston Pinkston
Subject:[Spam?] YMCA Greater Seattle, Rezone & Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Date:Friday, June 17, 2022 2:38:17 PM
Importance:Low
Acknowledgement of receipt of this email is requested.
June 17, 2022
Lewis County Planning Commission
Community Development
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA 98532
By Email
Commissioners,
As a property owner in Mineral, I am adamantly opposed to the proposed YMCA REZONEPROPOSAL. The proposal is a Seattle community problem looking for a solution in rural LewisCounty. The Seattle YMCA has indicated they are in need of additional camper capacity and thatLewis County provides the only feasible location for their future camping needs. This notion islaughable at best.
According to KingCounty.gov, there are more than 100 lakes in King County. That is a significant
recreational resource. Yet the Seattle YMCA found none of the lakes in King County suitable for their
camping needs. This leads to several conclusions. Seattle and King County have systematically
destroyed the native ecosystems surrounding their lakes. Urbanization of the region has erased the
opportunity for current and future generations to experience serene and native ecosystems. Simply
stated, they squandered and destroyed their native ecosystems. Now they want to come to remote
Lewis County and repeat the process.
The proposed Resort Overlay is nothing less than classic urban sprawl. This proposal epitomizes whythe Washington State legislature passed the Growth Management Act (GMA) in 1990. GMAidentifies remote uses that transition to urban uses. The transitions require associated infrastructureto support more intense uses. This proposal dumps an urban use into a remote location with nosupporting infrastructure.
As this proposal moves through the public process, I expect my elected and appointed
Commissioners to represent their constituents and not the Seattle/ King County special interest
associated with the YMCA. Do not move the YMCA REZONE PROPOSAL forward. This proposal
should not be forwarded to the Lewis County Commissioners for consideration.
Regards,
Eric D. Waters
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Mark Waters
To:Mindy Brooks; Megan Sathre; preston.pinkston@lewiscountywa.org
Subject:Mineral Re-Zone Public Comment
Date:Friday, June 17, 2022 2:54:11 PM
June 17, 2022
Lewis County Planning Board of Commissioners
Community Development 2025 NE Kresky Ave
Chehalis, WA 98532
Commissioners,
I, along with many other residents of the Mineral area, are absolutely
opposed to the Mineral Re-Zone.
I began coming to the Mineral area as a youth 50 or so years ago. It
was an area that my elder family members had come to know and love
after spending countless days camping, hunting and fishing. They
wanted my brothers, cousins and I to experience an area they were
completely and utterly enamored with. The beauty and tranquility were
second to none, and there was some darn good fishing to boot. When I
was old enough to hold a fishing rod, and trout season opened, my
Great Uncles would take us on weekly (yes, weekly) fishing trips to
Mineral Lake. The beauty, serenity and fishing were unrivaled!
When I became old enough to drive, and the elders could no longer
drive or manage their boat, I would take them…and so the tradition and
joy continued for many, many years to come.
Fast forward a few years (while continuing to frequent the area/lake), I
began dating my wife. After a several months of dating, Opening Day
of trout season comes along. I mention to my wife that my buddies
and I are going to Mineral Lake for opening day and she says, “You
should talk to my Grandpa and Grandma, they have property on Mineral
Lake.” Whaaaat?!! Naturally, I knew then, I HAD to marry this woman,
ha, ha, ha. All joking aside, I did marry her, and we had three
daughters.
As soon as the girls could walk, we were camping at the lake and
spending time on our boat fishing and swimming. Throughout their
years growing up, (they are now 25, 23 and 21) we would go camping,
fishing and swimming at Mineral several times a month throughout the
year. Seeing the excitement and joy in their eyes as young girls anytime
I mentioned going to the lake is something I will always cherish. They
would always comment about how beautiful and peaceful Mineral Lake
was and over the years have truly come to love the area, much like
their family before them.
The opportunity arose for us to purchase the property that belonged to
my wife’s Grandparents (164 Mineral Hill Rd). It was a no brainer, we
wanted to buy the property, but in order to make the purchase a
reality, we needed to restructure our family economic situation, which
was a bit of a challenge. But, understanding the memories that had
been made, with the opportunity for another generation to be able to
experience the same type of joys, we moved forward. We made the
necessary sacrifices to purchase the property so we could continue to
enjoy the area/lake and so our children could also watch their children
experience the same joys they did as children, and see the same look of
joy in their children’s eyes that we saw in our children’s eyes when at
the lake. We currently have a Grandson (16 months old) and have a
Granddaughter on the way. Our Grandson was playing in the lake at 6
months old and he loved it!….And so, the tradition continues. My heart
is full.
Unfortunately, this proposed Re-Zone stands to change the landscape,
not only physically, but also metaphorically, in a monumental and
irreversible way. Beyond the minimal ancillary benefits this Re-Zone
‘may’ bring to the greater local area, I cannot see one single,
significant, long-term benefit that this Re-Zone would bring that will
IMPROVE the quality of life for the residents of Mineral. The significant
increase in vehicle traffic, increased noise related to said vehicle and
pedestrian traffic, as well as the significant influx of people on the lake
during the best part of the fishing season, as well as throughout the
entire summer, would have an immense negative impact on what is,
and has been for decades, a very beautiful, peaceful and tranquil area.
A few things that come to mind regarding the Y’s degree of deception
to further their Re-zone request;
Their study that indicates limited signs of wildlife (specifically Elk) in the
area is laughable. I have several pictures of up to 20 or more elk
standing along Mineral Hill Rd and on our property.
Their water availability study numbers are grossly inaccurate since their
study was conducted during the wettest time of the year. This makes
their assertion that their drawing of water to supply the camp in the
summer, will not impact surrounding or area wells invalid as it is all
‘theory.’ Furthermore, some of the well depths they listed for area wells
are grossly inaccurate.
Waiting until the project application phase to begin a study to
determine what the traffic load and impacts will be is akin to buying a
horse and then trying to figure out how you are going to pay for feed.
Determining what the impacts on the Fire Dept., EMS and Law
Enforcement are due to the increase in population and how those
impacts will be mitigated, is also something that one does beforehand,
not after. ….and the list goes on.
The Greater YMCA of Seattle does not have the same vested interest in
the area as we area residents ourselves, and I can assure you, they will
not be the same type of stewarts of the area that we are. Instead of
destroying the very quality of life we have come to know and appreciate
the area for, let’s leave the urban-sprawl where it is, in King County.
This proposed Re-Zone is not congruent with the Growth Management
act (GMA) that the State passed in 1990 and should not occur in
Mineral. The infrastructure to support the types of projects which
would be allowed under the proposed Re-Zone does not exist.
Furthermore, though the documents related to this Re-Zone specify the
Re-Zone would only allow, tent sites, cabins, lodges and the like
associated with a ‘camp’ type facility, there is neither a County Code or
Ordinance, nor a State Statute or Washington Administrative Code
(WAC), that would prevent another Re-Zone amendment to this
proposed zoning amendment, which would allow single family, multi-
family, townhouse or apartment buildings. None of the above belong in
the remote rural community of Mineral.
I, along with my family and many area residence, am adamantly
opposed to this Re-Zone moving forward or receiving approval at any
level. I expect you to listen to your affected constituents and not be a
willing participant in helping to destroy the very quality of life we in
Mineral have come to know and love.
I request to be notified via email and US Mail, of any and all Public
meetings, applications, permits or submittals, as well as any associated
decisions by Lewis County and the State of Washington related to the
aforementioned Re-Zone and any subsequent projects applied for within
the entire proposed Re-Zone boundary.
Acknowledgement of this receipt is requested.
Regards
Mark Waters
33716 36th Ave E
Eatonville, WA 98328
Sent from Mail for Windows
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Mark Waters
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Lee Napier; Megan Sathre; BOCC; Tailor Arrington
Subject:Mineral Re-Zone Public Comments
Date:Friday, June 17, 2022 3:11:07 PM
June 17, 2022
Lewis County Planning Commission
Community Development
2025 NE Kresky Ave
Chehalis, WA. 98532
To whom it may concern,
I am a property owner in the town of Mineral. I, as well as many others, have serious concerns
about how the process regarding the proposed Re-Zone is playing out.
I first became aware of the project in August 2021 through a friend who indicated there was going
to be a town meeting regarding the project. Since then, there have been several additional
meetings and/or workshops, many of which I have attended either in-person or virtually via zoom. I
watched and listened as folk on both sides (opposed to or agree with) grew more passionate, vocal
and invested in having their voices heard.
In early April 2022 I heard that the upcoming meetings, specifically some of the workshops and
meetings involving public comment, were also going to be held via zoom.
I sent an email outlining the significance of the proposed Re-Zone and believed that due to the
significance of the potential impacts this Re-Zone could have, folk should be afforded the
opportunity to testify in-person.
I received an email back that read as follows;
“We have just started re-entry. We are beginning with inviting the Planning Commissioners back to
in person. Unfortunately, the security concerns have changed at the Historic Courthouse over the
past two years. Because the meetings are after regular business hours, the doors are locked and the
public is not able to enter the building.
We are continuing to use Zoom, which has been the primary tool for the past two years, for public
participation. We have also added YouTube, which also records meetings.”
I replied back, again indicating that due to the significance of the proposed Re-Zone and its potential
impacts, members of the community should be afforded the opportunity to provide in-person
testimony. I also inquired as to what the particular security concerns where/are?
I received a reply email which was nearly identical to the first, with no explanation as to what the
security concerns are which are prevented in-person meetings, but which reaffirmed that the
upcoming meetings would be conducted via Zoom and posted on YouTube. This was again affirmed
by the Planning Commission members at their May24th meeting.
Given the fact that the Planning Commission and Community Development have known that these
meeting will be occurring for almost a year, how can it be that no one possessed the forethought
and insight to develop a security plan and/or locate a suitable location so the community could
attend in-person and provide comment on such a significant proposal? I work for a city and have
been able to create and implement a security plan for events involving several hundreds of people in
a matter of hours, I don’t see this event as being any different.
Furthermore, it is unconscionable and irresponsible to believe that, given the extremely poor cell
phone and internet service in the Mineral area, the Planning Commission believes Zoom meetings
are a reliable platform for the Commission to hear public comment regarding a Re-Zone that will
impact so many people. This process has taken on an air of corruption and censorship. The
MINERAL COMMUNITY deserves a reasonable opportunity and a reliable means/platform to have
their voices heard, and as has been proven in the past by the volume of people who have lost
connectivity, Zoom HAS NOT been a reliable platform.
What are the security concerns that prevent the Planning Commission from holding YMCA Re-Zone
Public Comment meeting at the normally accustomed facility? Given the known ‘security concerns’,
why has no one taken the initiative or made the effort to adequately address those concerns by
formulating a security plan, or if formulating a security plan was not feasible, why did no one find a
secondary location to allow in-person public comment ?
In the spirit of transparency, please respond to this email and address all of the above questions so
we, as members of the community, have a better understanding of what we can expect from you in
the future.
In closing, if there is a true interest in involving the effected community in this process, we expect
these meetings to be held in-person, where everyone who wants to be heard, has the opportunity to
be heard.
Acknowledgement of receipt and reply to this correspondence is requested.
Regards,
Mark Waters
Sent from Mail for Windows
Sent from Mail for Windows
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
June 17, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. In my
opinion, the YMCA proposal is the best possible use for this property and would offer one of the lowest
development impacts to the surrounding community, while providing both economic and educational
benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and have
experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity
and inclusion to the outdoors, conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive
manner is important for today and future generations.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing
development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an
additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in
the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of
Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years
and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a
non-profit organization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would
benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities
for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found
that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education
experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools and
students.
For these reasons, I urge your approval of this project. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jefri Peters
jefripeters@gmail.com
206-412-2552
Ms. Mindy Brooks,
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
mindy.brooks@lewiscountywa.gov
RE: Proposed YMCA Camp on Mineral Lake June 19, 2022
Dear Ms. Brooks,
I am writing to support approval for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp
at Mineral Lake. I have served on both the Seattle YMCA Board and ’its Y
Camping Board for over 20 years. I know well the Y’s dedication to serving
children and families of all races, ethnicities, religions and status in
society. I also know Mineral Lake well, having hiked around it and its
surrounding lands; and how effectively the features, topography and
location will benefit campers of the Y’s exceptional Camp programming.
Rather than being developed for commercial or logging purposes (as has
been unsuccessfully tried); it is hard to imagine a more appropriate and
environmentally sensitive land use to address the important societal
needs of Lewis County citizens, and other surrounding communities.
The Y is fully committed to ensuring that all people, and especially young
people, can develop the outdoor knowledge and skills which will lead to
spending a lifetime engaged in and protective of the outdoors. Also, the
Y’s commitment to bringing diversity and inclusion to outdoor activities
is well established – as are its successes in delivering programs in an
environmentally responsible manner, important for today and the future.
For these and other important educational and social purposes, I urge
you to approve this project as an ideal use of this special property to
benefit Lewis County children and families.
Thank you very much.
Sincerely,
D T BOYDEN (signed)
Doug Boyden
YMCA of Greater Seattle Long-time Board and Camping Board Member
TUMAINI RUCKER COKER, MD, MBA
803 15th Ave East, Seattle WA 98112 | 310-663-6721 | tumaini.coker@gmail.com
June 19, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing this letter of support, as a community member, for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at
Mineral Lake. I offer this support as an individual, and as a mother with three children who have benefitted
from the rich experiences that the YMCA outdoor camps offer. I am also a Board Member for the YMCA of
Greater Seattle, so I have a good understanding of the potential economic impact of this proposal for the
communities in and around Lewis County.
I believe that the YMCA proposal offers an excellent use of the property, which benefits children and youth
in the county, and more broadly, in the state of Washington. The YMCA’s proposal for this property would
provide enormous economic, educational, and health benefits to children and families in the community.
The proposed project offers the following benefits to Lewis County:
-Economic Development and Jobs. The YMCA project would use local contractors to develop the site
over the next 10 years and provide ongoing services as needed.
-Tax Revenue. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profit organization, this
project will also generate additional tax revenues that would benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis
County.
-More opportunities for Youth to Engage in Outdoor Activity. Research has shown that outdoor
activity for children and youth, K-12, has clear benefits on mental health, physical health, and wellness.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Tumaini Rucker Coker, MD, MBA
June 20, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my strong support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. I serve
on the board of directors of the YMCA of Greater Seattle, and I am also a parent with camp-aged
children who are looking forward to YMCA summer camps.
I have been able to visit the proposed site twice, and have been struck by its natural beauty, and by how
perfect the site could be for a camp that serves youth from around the region. I just can’t imagine a
more appropriate, desirable use for the site than a YMCA camp! One thing that has always been
important to me about the Seattle Y camps at Camp Colman and Camp Orkila is that they operate on a
sliding scale, in order to allow children from different economic background to participate. I know the Y
would have similar arrangements for a camp at Mineral Lake, giving youth in our region a fantastic
‘mountain camp’ option for summer and year-round youth development.
I have also seen how camp has positive economic impacts on the surrounding community, including
good year-round and seasonal jobs, and support for local businesses. I think the same positive impacts
will occur here.
One of the Y’s top goals is to preserve the natural beauty of this incredible site, and I know from Camp
Colman, Camp Orkila, and the Y’s other activities that it will be an excellent steward of this property and
an excellent partner with the county and other local agencies.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your
consideration.
Sincerely,
Aaron Perrine
Managing Director, Trilogy Search Partners
aaron@trilogy-search.com
Copy to: ceo@seattleymca.org and gbagley@seattleymca.org
From:BARBARA DINGFIELD
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:ceo@seattleymca.org; gbagley@seattleymca.org
Subject:Mineral Lake
Date:Tuesday, June 21, 2022 10:29:42 AM
June 21, 2022
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing, as a parent, a grandparent and a longtime supporter of the YMCA, to state my support
for the YMCA’s proposed camp at Mineral Lake. The YMCA proposal is an excellent use for this
property and would offer one of the lowest development impacts to the surrounding community,
while providing both economic and educational benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and
have experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. My son attended a YMCA
camp many years ago and learned a great deal about the outdoors and about working and playing
with others from diverse communities.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing
development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an
additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use
in the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part
of Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10
years and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax
exemption as a non-profit organization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax
revenues that would benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education
opportunities for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the
Legislature found that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing
outdoor education experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those
opportunities for schools and students.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your
consideration.
Sincerely,
Barbara Dingfield
barbarajd@msn.com
3201 Magnolia Blvd. W
Seattle, WA 98199
From:Hannah Mason
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:proposal for Y camp at Mineral Lake
Date:Monday, June 20, 2022 11:40:19 AM
Dear Ms. Brooks,
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. As a
longtime Y staff, my view is undoubtedly biased but as someone who has spent many years working
with teens I can attest firsthand to the value that getting kids outdoors plays in their lives, as well
as how it benefits our state and world.
Growing up in Monroe WA, I had a father that loved to take me hiking and fishing in the foothills of
the Cascades. It taught me to respect nature and grew in me a deep love of the outdoors and the
importance of taking care of our outdoor spaces. Many of the teens I have worked with over the
years did not have these opportunities, either because their parents never did, or their parents did
not have the means to get them outdoors. Leading Y wilderness expeditions was one of my favorite
parts of my job because you could really see the change in teens as they learned to respect and
navigate the outdoors.
One excursion I will never forget was a day hike we took with a group of teen boys on who had never
been hiking in their life. At first they were a bit incredulous, why would anyone want to do this? But
we convinced them it would be fun so they trusted us and went. When we finally made it to the
destination they were completely won over by the beautiful views and adrenaline that comes with
hiking and ascending a summit. It seemed like a normal trip until we saw a few of the teens a
few weeks later at a Y program. They shared that the following day they had returned to the trail on
their own with their cousins and had hiked the same trail again. Then the next week, they had taken
their entire family to the same hike. They had enjoyed it so much that they had to share it with the
rest of their family. It was so moving to me that these teens had returned multiple times because of
that one outdoor experience they had. I have witnessed and heard so many experiences like this,
whether hiking or at overnight camp through the Y, it truly touches kids lives and helps them learn
about themselves and others in positive ways.
Y outdoor programs and camps also teach kids how to respect nature and each other, which is
something that is deeply needed in our state. Hiking and camping have become more and more
popular and as it grows the need for outdoor education grows too. Y outdoor education also brings
together kids from very different backgrounds and experiences, which really helps them learn and
respect each other, something that is very important as our political landscape becomes more and
more polarized. The Y core values are always taught (honesty, respect, caring and responsibility) in
our youth programming and I’ve seen these values bring kids together who would have never seen
eye to eye in normal settings. I think this is something our world needs a lot more of these days.
Whether it is a y camp, school, or other youth organization, I am such a huge advocate for getting
more kids outdoors so they can learn about themselves, others and how to respect and care for
nature and our world. I cannot stress enough how important these opportunities are for our youth.
For these reasons, I urge your approval of this project. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Hannah Mason
20218 24th Ave NE
Shoreline, WA 98155
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Alan Pickerill
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Loria Yeadon, President/CEO; gbagley@seattleymca.org
Subject:Mineral Lake / YMCA
Date:Monday, June 20, 2022 1:13:48 PM
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my strong support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp
at Mineral Lake. I have lived in Washington my entire life and have been involved
with and supportive of the YMCA for a long while.
In my opinion, the YMCA proposal is an outstanding potential use for this property
and would offer one of the lowest development impacts to the surrounding
community, while providing both economic and educational benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can
develop the skills and have experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the
outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity and inclusion to the outdoors,conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive manner isimportant for today and future generations.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years,including a housing development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres andhas indicated it plans to purchase an additional 1,600 acres, developing only a
fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in the practice of
sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and
jobs to this part of Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors
to develop the site over the next 10 years and provide ongoing services as
needed.Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profitorganization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that
would benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdooreducation opportunities for local students and those from around the state. A recent
study conducted for the Legislature found that more must be done to equitably meet
the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education experiences. The YMCA
camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools andstudents.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank
you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Alan Pickerill
YMCA Board MemberFormer CFO Expedia Group
Copy to: ceo@seattleymca.org and gbagley@seattleymca.org
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensure
the message is legitimate before opening it.
From:Ragen, Cameron B
To:Mindy Brooks
Cc:Loria Yeadon, President/CEO; gbagley@seattleymca.org
Subject:Mineral Lake and the YMCA of Greater Seattle
Date:Monday, June 20, 2022 2:07:55 PM
June 20, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
As a board member of the YMCA of Greater Seattle I am writing to offer
my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. Inmy opinion, the YMCA proposal is the best possible use for this property
and would offer one of the lowest development impacts to the surrounding
community, while providing both economic and educational benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people,
can develop the skills and have experiences to spend a lifetime actively
engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity and
inclusion to the outdoors, conservation efforts, and delivering programs ina culturally responsive manner is important for today and future
generations.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years,including a housing development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an additional 1,600 acres,
developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for
use in the practice of sustainable forestry. I serve on the DevelopmentCommittee of the Y and we are working hard to bring in donors to supportthis land acquisition.
I also serve on the Finance Committee of the Y so dollars and cents areimportant to me. I especially like this project because it will bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of Lewis County. The
Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the
next 10 years and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y doesnot intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profit organization at thistime, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would
benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for
outdoor education opportunities for local students and those from aroundthe state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found that more
must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing
outdoor education experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would
help provide those opportunities for schools and students.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Cam Ragen
Financial Advisor, Managing Director
The Ragen Group
Baird Private Wealth Management925 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3600Seattle WA 98104THE RAGEN GROUP
Our Profile–Our Practice
Barron’s Top 1,200 Ranked Advisor 2015 - 2022Financial Times Top 400 Advisor 2016, 2020
(206) 464-3171 - Direct
Robert W. Baird & Co. Incorporated does not accept buy, sell or other transaction orders by e-mail, or any instructions by e-mail that require a signature. This e-mail message, and any
attachment(s), is not an offer, or solicitation of an offer, to buy or sell any security or otherproduct. Unless otherwise specifically indicated, information contained in this communication
is not an official confirmation of any transaction or an official statement of Baird. Theinformation provided is subject to change without notice. This e-mail may contain privileged
or confidential information or may otherwise be protected by law, rule or regulation. Any use,copying or distribution of the information contained in this e-mail by persons or entities other
than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact thesender, and delete the material from any computer on which it exists. Baird, in accordance
with applicable law, reserves the right to monitor, review and retain all electroniccommunications, including e-mails, traveling through its networks and systems. E-mail
transmissions cannot be guaranteed to be secure, timely or error-free. Baird thereforerecommends that you do not send any sensitive information such as account or personal
identification numbers by e-mail.
Please click here <https://www.bairdwealth.com/globalassets/pdfs/help/consolidated-report-disclosure.pdf> for important information about any client reports you receive.
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
From:Robert Richards
To:Mindy Brooks
Subject:YMCA Rezone and Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Date:Monday, June 20, 2022 7:01:19 AM
Dear Ms. Brooks,
As Senior Long-Range Planner of the Lewis County Planning Department, you areconsidering a project of immense benefit to Lewis County accompanied by little negative
impact. I would appreciate your transmitting this letter of support to the members of theLewis County Planning Commission. Thank you.
Dear Members of the Lewis County Planning Commission:
The proposed YMCA camp for youth and families at Mineral Lake is the best possible use forthis property, offering one of the lowest development impacts to the surrounding community
by removing this particular site from the various commercial proposals in recent years,including a housing development, devoting most of the property to sustained forestry and only
a fraction to camp activities. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated itplans to purchase an additional 1,600 acres.
At the same time, this project will provide jobs in this part of Lewis County, seeking localcontractors to develop the site over the next ten years and provide ongoing services as needed.
Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profit organization at thistime, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would benefit both Mineral
and the rest of Lewis County.
Perhaps most importantly, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for
outdoor education opportunities for local students and around the state. The proposed campwill serve as an important resource for school districts as they pursue their environmental
education objectives. Throughout the United States the YMCA has a stellar record ofoperating camps, providing youth with an opportunity to develop the skills and have
experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. For generations the YMCAof Greater Seattle has operated outstanding camps in the San Juan Islands and southern Puget
Sound, enjoying harmonious relations with the camps’ neighbors and providing opportunitiesto the local community. The YMCA would do the same at Mineral Lake.
The YMCA of Greater Seattle looks forward to becoming a responsible member of theMineral community. Thank you for your consideration.
Robert R. Richards
Robert R. Richards
former director, YMCA of the USA
rrichards11@icloud.com
206-310-1191
June X, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. In my
opinion, the YMCA proposal is the best possible use for this property and would offer one of the lowest
development impacts to the surrounding community, while providing both economic and educational
benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and have
experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity
and inclusion to the outdoors, conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive
manner is important for today and future generations.
This particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing
development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an
additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in
the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of
Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years
and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a
non-profit organization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would
benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities
for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found
that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education
experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools and
students.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your
consideration.
Sincerely,
Cynthia Sonstelie
Sonstelie@aol.com
206-334-0949
Copy to: ceo@seattleymca.org and gbagley@seattleymca.org
June 21, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing you to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. As a
longtime YMCA board member, I have seen firsthand the tremendous benefits that camps like these
offer both to participants and the local community. In my opinion, the YMCA proposal is the best
possible use for this property and would offer one of the lowest development impacts to the
surrounding community, while providing both economic and educational benefits.
I understand that this particular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a
housing development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to
purchase an additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of the site and leaving the rest of the land
for use in the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of
Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years
and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a
non-profit organization at this time, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would
benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities
for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found
that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education
experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools and
students.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your
consideration.
Sincerely,
Trevor Stuart, CPA
Board Member, YMCA of Greater Seattle
Email: tstuart@kitsapcu.org
Mobile: (206) 755-0416
Copy to: ceo@seattleymca.org and gbagley@seattleymca.org
YMCA OF GREATER SEATTLE
909 4th Avenue, Seattle, WA 98104
P 206 382 5000 F 206 382 7283 seattleymca.org
June 21, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. The YMCA’s proposal
would be an incredible, community-focused use of this property and would offer one of the lowest development
impacts to the surrounding community, while providing both economic and educational benefits locally.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and have
experiences to spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity and
inclusion to the outdoors, conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive manner is
important for today and future generations.
This site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing development. Thus far, the
YMCA has purchased 500 acres and intends to purchase an additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of
the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of Lewis
County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years and provide
ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profit organization at
this time, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would benefit both Mineral and the rest of
Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities for local
students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found that more must be
done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education experiences. The YMCA camp
at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools and students.
For these reasons, I humbly request your approval of this project. Thank you for your consideration.
In community,
Loria Yeadon
President & CEO
lyeadon@seattleymca.org
June 22, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing on behalf of Centralia College to express our support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight
camp at Mineral Lake. Outdoor education is crucial for each generation of children, and the YMCA has a
long history of experience helping children learn about and enjoy our natural habitat. The proposed
YMCA development at Mineral Lake is an excellent use of this beautiful property and would provide
both economic and educational benefits to the local community.
As you may be aware, Centralia College operates a satellite campus in Morton, known as CC East. While
this is a small site that serves a relatively small number of students, we feel that it is vital to promoting
the educational needs of East Lewis County. We see the YMCA development as a tremendous
opportunity for partnership and we look forward to working with the YMCA and other community
partners to develop appropriate programs and events.
The YMCA proposal will fit in well in East County. The overnight camp and education center will be
relatively low impact developments, and the eventual plan for up to 2100 acres would preserve much of
the site for sustainable forestry. CC East currently offers Wildland Firefighter Certification training. We
believe that the YMCA plan would present other opportunities for partnership and new programs in
coming years.
This project is likely to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of Lewis County.
The YMCA has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years and
provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-
profit organization, this project will also generate additional tax revenues that would benefit both
Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
The proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities for local
students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found that more
must be done to meet the needs of young students in providing outdoor education experiences. The
YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportunities for schools and students.
For these reasons, I urge your approval of this project. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Bob Mohrbacher
Bob Mohrbacher, President
Centralia College
(360) 623-8552
bob.mohrbacher@centralia.edu
801 Second Avenue, Suite 1700
Seattle, WA 98104
LAIRDNORTONPROPERTIES.COM
June 22, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Avenue
Chehalis, Washington 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am writing to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. In my opinion, the YMCA pro-
posal is the highest and best possible use for this property as it would offer one of the lowest development impacts to
the surrounding community, while providing both economic and educational benefits.
The Y is committed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and have experiences to
spend a lifetime actively engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity and inclusion to the outdoors,
conservation efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive manner is important for today and future gener-
ations.
This site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing development. Thus far, the YMCA
has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an additional 1,600 acres, developing only a fraction of
the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in the practice of sustainable forestry.
Additionally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of Lewis County. The
Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years and provide ongoing services as
needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exemption as a non-profit organization at this time, this project will
also generate additional tax revenues that would benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor education opportunities for local students
and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found that more must be done to equita-
bly meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor education experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would
help provide those opportunities for schools and students.
For these reasons, I give my strongest recommendation that you approve this project. Thank you in advance for your
consideration and please feel free to reach out with any questions.
Sincerely,
Jim Reinhardsen
President, Laird Norton Properties
(206) 409-7113
Reinhardsen.j@lnproperties.com
From:Jane Seibel
To:Mindy Brooks
Date:Thursday, June 23, 2022 1:29:43 PM
To whom it may concern I want to list my support for the YMCA project at Mineral Lake. The At has supported
communities throughout our country as stewards of the land and of our citizens from youngchildren to elderly of all walks of life.
The Y has committed a very thorough investigation into suitible properties to bring children tolearn and fall in love with the land and learn to be good stewards of the land as well as strong
community members and kind people.The Y educates the whole person.
As has been seen in other campCommunities such as Coleman and Orkilla the At has served to feed and support communities
during crises such as Covid-19 when others could not. They provided childcare and camps forworking parents and tie children to a love and fun of the outdoors through healthy bodies and
healthy spirits.I fully support the creation of the Y property at Mineral Lake.
Jane SeibelY board member
6702 34 th ave Nw Seattle Wa 98117
External Email - Remember to think before you click!
This message may contain links with malware, viruses, etc. Please ensurethe message is legitimate before opening it.
To: Mindy Brooks (Lewis County Planning)
Gwen Ichinose Bagley (YMCA)
June 26, 2022
Re: YMCA Camp at Mineral Lake
My name is Jane Hodges and I divide my time between Seattle and Mineral, where I have been a part-
time resident since 2013, when I bought the town’s surplus elementary school from the Morton
School District as the site of a nonprofit artist residency program we call Mineral School. While I do
not have deep roots in Lewis County, I do see Mineral through the eyes of a writer and the landscape
for writers, and that is why I invested in property here. Mineral School is a place where artists from
throughout the Northwest (and North America) who are vetted in an application process can come to
find peace and quiet in which to produce new work, while also living in a small, active logging
community in the foothills of Mt. Rainier and engaging in informal connection with the environment,
the history, the landscape, and locals who join us at free events or along the lake or at the tavern.
Mineral is a beautiful community boasting a pristine fishing lake, an aging population, and a shrinking
economy, with a strong network of community organizations — church groups, a food bank, luncheon
clubs, the Lions Club, a fire department, and nascent groups forming programs for children, etc. While
collaborative and friendly, it is also at times resistant to change and suspicious of anyone who isn’t
already from the area. (I am in the process of selling the building, with the artist residency nonprofit
remaining a tenant, and gossip around what “the lady who owns the school” is up to reveals a lot of
suspicion and sexism.)
Today I am writing in support of a YMCA camp and program site for children, and the partnership
between the YMCA and the Nisqually Indian Tribe. Just as I believe artists need space and support to
grow their creative work, I also know that children need time and experience in nature and in safe,
supervised communities in order to grow into adults with curiosity, empathy, self-esteem, and
practical and teamwork skills required for them to feel confident that they can thrive. In particular,
children who live landlocked in downtowns and urban corridors, or suburban landscapes, need access
to quiet, natural spaces where animals and bodies of water and mountains and trails and campfires
and adventures can be shared. I have heard multiple people in town say they resist the camp project
because “they’ll bus in inner city children” — “inner city” being code for children of color, children
from cities, children who may not live where their parents grew up. Mineral residents may enjoy their
current view of the lake and lack of traffic along Mineral Hill Road, but who is the town if its resources
are hoarded for a few landowners who like their views and the lake is not shared with all people who
deserve time in nature? I understand concerns about emergency response, traffic, and lifestyle
changes full-time residents may experience as a camp develops. These concerns are logistical and the
solutions to them may be costly, but they can be negotiated and fundraised.
I keep circling back to the bigger picture. My support for the YMCA/Nisqually project stems from my
belief that all people deserve to feel safe and welcome in the outdoors, and that a homogenous
community runs the risk of sinking in on itself as a closed places that fears outsiders or “others” and
creates social systems of “us” and “them.” As a person who brings in small batches of artists — a
majority of them LGBTQ+, many People of Color — I too am “bussing in the inner city,” as well as the
mistrusted academic town and those cars with much-mocked liberal bumper stickers, on a small
scale. The reality is that American demography is changing, and the future is not white — not even in
the countryside. I and others involved in our project have begun the homework of learning how non-
white folks experience the rural, both through book learning and through listening to the experiences
of artists in our care: Gay people unsure if it’s safe to take walks due to past gay-bashing experiences,
Black artists who trade mobile numbers with me “in case of emergency” before venturing on a hike or
to the tavern alone, People of Color followed slowly by local cars, or concerned about the hateful
messages relayed by Confederate flags and bumper stickers. We need to make sure that everyone
feels as free to enjoy the rural as white people do, starting in childhood.
It is my belief that the YMCA could not choose a better location than Mineral in which to site its new
camp. The Y, while using its proven methods for managing successful camps throughout Washington,
can deliver its services to children and expand its capacity while also honoring the history of the land
which belongs to the Nisqually Indian Tribe. Mineral can watch, learn, and benefit from the potential
for new employment opportunities and become a diverse and inclusive community centered around
natural resources including (but also expanding beyond) the logging trade. In time, whether Mineral
grows or not, the Y’s presence can make it a place where women, children, and minorities are granted
as much visibility and respect as those who for far too long have spoken for and over their voices,
laying the groundwork for it to become a place that welcomes everyone and includes industries that
deliver nurture and nature as well as resource extraction and exploitation — an economy including
industry, but also including love.
Sincerely,
Jane Hodges
June 25, 2022
Ms. Mindy Brooks
Senior Long-Range Planner
Lewis County Planning Department
2025 NE Kresky Ave.
Chehalis, WA, 98532
Dear Ms. Brooks:
I am wriNng to offer my support for the YMCA’s proposed overnight camp at Mineral Lake. In my opinion,
the YMCA proposal is the best possible use for this property and would offer one of the lowest
development impacts to the surrounding community, while providing both economic and educaNonal
benefits.
The Y is commiWed to ensuring that all people, especially young people, can develop the skills and have
experiences to spend a lifeNme acNvely engaged in the outdoors. The Y’s commitment to bringing equity
and inclusion to the outdoors, conservaNon efforts, and delivering programs in a culturally responsive
manner is important for today and future generaNons.
I am a personal example of this commitment. I grew up in the Y, parNcipated in sports, swam, was a
camper and subsequently served as a lifeguard and camp counselor. The Y experience is a real learning
opportunity for youth and supports their growth to mature and caring adults.
This parNcular site has been the focus of various proposals in recent years, including a housing
development. Thus far, the YMCA has purchased 500 acres and has indicated it plans to purchase an
addiNonal 1,600 acres, developing only a fracNon of the site and leaving the rest of the land for use in
the pracNce of sustainable forestry.
AddiNonally, this project stands to bring much-needed economic development and jobs to this part of
Lewis County. The Y has indicated it will seek local contractors to develop the site over the next 10 years
and provide ongoing services as needed. Because the Y does not intend to seek a tax exempNon as a
non-profit organizaNon at this Nme, this project will also generate addiNonal tax revenues that would
benefit both Mineral and the rest of Lewis County.
Finally, the proposed camp would help address the growing need for outdoor educaNon opportuniNes
for local students and those from around the state. A recent study conducted for the Legislature found
that more must be done to equitably meet the needs of K-12 students in providing outdoor educaNon
experiences. The YMCA camp at Mineral Lake would help provide those opportuniNes for schools and
students.
For these reasons, I strongly recommend your approval of this project. Thank you for your consideraNon.
Sincerely,
Meredith Mathews, MD MPH
Meredith Mathews, MD MPH
12709A 42nd Ave NE
Seattle, WA 98125
Phone: 206 228 7495